Everton 2-0 Manchester City

Manchester City may have left Goodison Park with a feeling of injustice but the problems lay deeper than a refereeing error. Sure, Marouane Fellaini’s handball should have been awarded as a penalty and should City have scored they may have gone on to win the game – or at least gain a point. The situation, however, is hypothetical and in reality the Blues got exactly what they deserved.

Everton had a point to prove although they never need firing up to play Manchester City. A shambolic defeat in the FA Cup last week against Wigan ended all hopes of a trophy, in a competition deemed as winnable, as David Moyes approaches the end of his 11th year in charge of the club.

For City though, sitting 15 points behind Manchester United, it was a chance to show that they had what it takes to claw the title back. They didn’t. City fans often sing about fighting ‘til the end, following the heroics of last season, but the 11 boys masquerading as men at Goodison Park showed no sign of that famous spirit.

The cliché of modern Premier League football is whether a player can ‘perform on a rainy day in Stoke?’ It should be changed to can they ‘perform on a rainy day in Merseyside?’ It is clear Manchester City cannot.

Roberto Mancini’s future is in doubt and there are many who remain unconvinced that he will be at the helm next season. All is not lost for the Blues, who have the FA Cup semi-final to look forward to in four weeks time. Indeed, if it is City’s name on the trophy as it was two seasons ago then a second placed finish and the FA Cup may spare the Italian.

But performances like the one at Everton will not help his cause and tactical changes that could have made a difference were enforced far too late. It was evident from the opening ten minutes that Edin Dzeko was set to be little more than a passenger for the Blues. Worryingly he was not the only one. When Steven Pienaar was correctly sent off for two yellow cards, City should have taken the game to Everton. Real Madrid managed to do just that against Manchester United at Old Trafford two weeks ago, but the Blues were incapable.

Despite a 15 point deficit on neighbours United, some City fans remain optimistic that they can retain their title, looking back to last season as inspiration. It won’t happen. They can’t witness performances like the one at Everton and then re-watch Sergio Aguero’s goal against QPR and expect lightning to strike twice. The season is over and the best thing the Blues can hope for is the FA Cup and second place.

Over the course of 38 games last season, City deserved to win the title. They were the better side for the majority of the campaign and made history. This year they have not and that is why the trophy is returning to Old Trafford.


Published by

Matt Hill

Hi there! I'm Matt Hill, a 22-year-old sports journalist and broadcaster. Welcome to The Rising Blue. A blog predominantly about Manchester City FC. Thanks for visiting my site. If you like what you read (or don't like) hit me up for a chat on Twitter or add your comments to the story. You'll find me here: @matty_hill Any questions/recommendations/queries for the site or myself can be sent to matty.a.hill@gmail.com

7 thoughts on “Everton 2-0 Manchester City”

  1. Why no mention of Mirallas goal which was incorrectlt ruled out for offside. As for Pienaar sending off, suggest you have a look at footage again, and see if you can see any contact. At best it was absolutely minimal. Never enough to warrant a yellow card.

    1. Didn’t need to mention Mirallas goal – though yes it should have stood. Pienaar was definitely a yellow card offence and as it was his second he was correctly sent off.

  2. How can you talk with any seriousness about a ‘sense of injustice’? Everton had a legitimate goal disallowed and as good a claim for a penalty turned down as the one you mention. Have these been erased from your memory?

    1. I never said I felt injustice, It’s clear that I believe the best team won the game. I’m critical of City’s performance as this is a blog about Manchester City. This isn’t about Everton nor is this a match report.

  3. Injustice? What are you on? If the bloody referee had eyes to see you’d have been 3 – 0 down, dead and buried by half-time. Yes, Fellaini’s handball was a penalty, but so was the first-half foul on him. And how he didn’t book Milner for the game’s worst foul (not even a free bloody kick!) or Dzecko for a blatant dive Christ alone knows. The better side won, and only a classless gutless no-mark like Mancini would dispute it.

    1. Injustice as in the team felt they should have had a penalty. I’m quite clearly critical of the City performance and saying that Everton deserved a win. This isn’t a match report I’m merely making the point that City’s performance wasn’t good enough and that the lack of a penalty is not an excuse.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s